Game designer Uwe Rosenburg continues to revolutionize worker placement games. His Harvest Trilogy (Agricola, Le Havre, & At the Gates of Loyang), as well as his latest game Ora et Labora, all focus on complex economic themes. Although Bohnanza, his first game, was not a worker placement game.
Agricola (2007)
I have mentioned some of my feelings regarding Agricola before. I have played Agricola a few times. My main complaint is not that the game is "too hard", but rather that I feel like I have lost in the first round. Before I had played any of his other games, I had written off Rosenburg's worker placement games as something I just could not do.
It feels as if too much is going on in the game. First you start with a negative score. Not only do you need at least one of each animal, you have to expand your family, feed them, upgrade your house, etc. I get tired just thinking about it. Then throw in occupations, minor and major improvements and fighting over Start Player, it gets even more overwhelming. I'm still willing to attempt to play Agricola again, but it does really frustrate me. And I have found playing with certain people make it even more frustrating.
Most games of Agricola have at least one player who has a much lower score. This is usually due to the fact that that player is getting screwed on expanding your family, upgrading your house and/ or resources. I honestly do not know why so many people enjoy Agricola. Why would you play a game you can get screwed over badly (in the first turn in my case)?
I did manage to successfully not suck at Rosenburg's new 2 player game Agricola: All Creatures Big and Small (ACBS) (2012). This version is a shorter, lighter version of Agricola that focuses on just acquiring animals, not feeding your people, getting more people, upgrading your house, etc. ACBS does not penalize you for empty board spaces, though it does if you have fewer than 3 of each of the types of animals. Overall this is a less frustrating version of Agricola.
Le Havre (2008)
I have only played the board game version of Le Havre once, but have played the iOS version numerous times. Le Havre is a much more relatable game. Feeding your people is easier given the relative ease in stockpiling food, building ships, etc. Although there are a lot of choices to make through out the game, there is a lot less direct competition for resources and buildings. Additionally, buildings can be shared (with entry fee payment), which reduces frustration levels. I would claim that this is my favorite Rosenburg worker placement game, but I think that's based on the fact that I have played it more than Ora et Labora.
At The Gates of Loyang (2009)
I have played At The Gates of Loyang several times. It does not seem to fit well with the other two games of the Harvest Trilogy. It is a much simpler game (but not in a bad way). There is no feeding your people aspect. Furthermore you actual buy your points at the end of your turn, instead of buying buildings and acquiring animals worth points. There is the farmer aspect of planting veggies like Agricola. Aside from Agricola, this is my least favorite Rosenburg game.
Ora et Labora (2011)
I just learned Ora et Labora and I only played Ireland. Ora makes use of double-sided resource tiles (à Le Havre) but introduces a new resource wheel. This resource wheel allows players to more easily keep track of growing available resources each turn. Buildings have resource costs, as well as terrain restrictions. Some buildings each player has in their own deck, while others players compete to build. Players can also make use of other players' buildings, like Le Havre. I would definitely want to play this game again.
Final Thoughts.
One aspect all of Rosenburg's games have in common, is that they all feature a solo game variant. This provides game owners with much more versatility.
Final Scores.
Listing Rosenburg's worker placement games from my favorite to least:
Le Havre
Ora et Labora (though this could surpass Le Havre if I play it more)
Agricola: ACBS
At The Gates of Loyang
Agricola (though this has the potential to surpass and possibly ACBS if I can ever get the game!!)
No comments:
Post a Comment